MA WILLS AND TRUSTS: The Only Law We Practice.
A nice day today, eh?
Learn the basics of MA Estate Planning in just 5 days.
A free, 5-day email course to demystify estate planning. It’s not that complicated.
SEND ME FREE LESSONS
Bonus Lesson: A durable power of attorney can be rejected.
In Massachusetts, the Durable Power of Attorney (DPOA) is a crucial legal document that allows an individual to appoint someone to manage their affairs. However, questions often arise about the longevity and effectiveness of a DPOA, particularly when compared to alternatives like living trusts.
Durable Power of Attorney: Age and Validity
A Durable Power of Attorney in Massachusetts is designed to remain effective even if the principal becomes incapacitated. However, its effectiveness can be questioned due to its age, leading to the concept of a document being "stale". Financial institutions and other entities might be hesitant to honor an older DPOA due to concerns about its current relevance or fear of fraud. For example, a bank may reject a 10-year-old DPOA, worrying whether the principal has revoked it or made changes since its execution.
This hesitation is not without legal basis. The Uniform Power of Attorney Act, adopted by some states though not yet by Massachusetts as of my last update, addresses this issue by prohibiting third parties from rejecting a DPOA solely based on its duration since execution. However, in the absence of such statutory protection in Massachusetts, the discretion largely lies with the entity to which the DPOA is presented.
Living Trusts as a Superior Alternative
In contrast to a DPOA, a living trust in Massachusetts offers a more robust solution for managing an individual's affairs. A living trust involves placing assets into a trust, managed by a trustee for the benefit of the trust's beneficiaries. This arrangement can be more favorable for several reasons.
Firstly, a living trust is generally more readily accepted by financial institutions and other entities. Unlike a DPOA, which may be scrutinized for its age, the ongoing nature of a trust conveys a sense of permanence and current relevance.
Secondly, a living trust provides a higher degree of control over assets. The trust document can specify in detail how assets are to be managed and distributed, a level of specificity not usually found in a DPOA.
For instance, consider a scenario where an individual has set up a living trust for their real estate holdings. The trust document can articulate precise instructions for the property's management, ensuring that the individual's wishes are honored even if they become incapacitated.
Detailed Comparison of DPOA and Living Trusts
Understanding the distinction between a DPOA and a living trust is crucial. While both serve to manage assets and decisions, their legal standing and acceptance can vary significantly, particularly when an older DPOA is compared with a freshly administered trust.
Risks Associated with Stale DPOAs
The risk of a DPOA being rejected due to age is not merely theoretical. In Massachusetts, as in other jurisdictions, the absence of clear legal guidelines about the 'shelf life' of a DPOA leaves room for subjective judgment by third parties. For instance, a financial institution may refuse a DPOA that is several years old, fearing it does not accurately reflect the current intentions of the principal. This concern is particularly valid if the principal has become incapacitated and cannot confirm the DPOA's validity. Such rejections can lead to significant delays and complications in financial management, especially in urgent situations.
Advantages of Living Trusts in Continuity and Control
Living trusts address many of these concerns inherent to DPOAs. The trust document, once established, acts as a clear directive for the management of the assets it contains. This ongoing management under the trust is less likely to be questioned by third parties, as the trust is perceived as an active, current instrument. Additionally, living trusts offer a level of detail and control over assets that DPOAs typically lack. For instance, a trust can dictate specific terms for asset distribution, care of minors, or business management, which are not usually within the scope of a DPOA. This specificity ensures that an individual's wishes are followed closely, reducing the chances of misinterpretation or mismanagement.
In summary, while a Massachusetts Durable Power of Attorney provides a valuable tool for estate planning, its vulnerability to being considered stale makes it less reliable than a living trust. Living trusts offer a more enduring, detailed, and accepted means of managing one's affairs, particularly in the long term.
Monday - Friday: 9am-5pm Saturday/Sunday: CLOSED