Introduction

Of all the medical decisions you might face in your lifetime, the most critical ones could potentially be made when you're unable to speak for yourself. Who would decide whether to continue life support if you were in a coma? Who would choose between competing treatment options if you were unconscious after an accident? Who would communicate your wishes about pain management during a terminal illness if you couldn't articulate them yourself?

In Massachusetts, without proper planning, these intensely personal decisions could be made by doctors who don't know your values, family members who don't know your wishes, or even courts applying generic standards that might have little to do with what you would actually want.

A health care proxy—sometimes called a medical power of attorney in other states—is Massachusetts' legal solution to this problem. This relatively simple document allows you to name someone you trust to make health care decisions for you when you cannot make or communicate them yourself. Think of it as appointing your own medical ambassador—someone who knows your values, understands your preferences, and can advocate for your wishes when you're unable to do so yourself.

This guide covers everything you need to know about health care proxies—why they're essential (regardless of your age or health status), how they work, how to create a valid one, and how to ensure it actually reflects your wishes when it matters most.

Why Every Massachusetts Adult Needs a Health Care Proxy

Many people assume health care proxies are only necessary for the elderly or those with chronic illnesses. In reality, every adult in Massachusetts should have one, regardless of age or current health status. Here's why:

Medical Emergencies Can Happen to Anyone

Accidents and unexpected medical events don't discriminate by age:

• A 25-year-old rock climber falls and sustains a head injury
• A 35-year-old parent has an unexpected allergic reaction
• A 45-year-old business traveler experiences a stroke in a distant city
• A 65-year-old retiree develops sudden complications during routine surgery

In each of these scenarios, temporary incapacity might require someone else to make urgent medical decisions. Without a health care proxy, Massachusetts has no clear legal mechanism for determining who makes those decisions, potentially leading to delays in treatment, family conflicts, or decisions that don't align with your wishes.

Modern Medicine Creates Complex Choices

Medical technology has advanced faster than most people's understanding of it. Treatment options now include:

• Various levels of life support (ventilation, feeding tubes, etc.)
• Experimental treatments with uncertain outcomes
• Complex risk/benefit calculations for procedures
• Quality of life considerations alongside survival rates

These nuanced decisions require someone who understands not just what treatments you would want, but why you would want them—the values and priorities that would guide your own decision-making if you could speak for yourself.

Massachusetts Law Provides No Clear Default

Unlike some states with established surrogate decision-making hierarchies, Massachusetts has no comprehensive statutory framework establishing who can automatically make decisions for an incapacitated person who lacks a health care proxy. This legal gap means that without a proxy:

• Medical providers might defer to family members without clear legal authority
• Disagreements between family members could go unresolved
• Court intervention might be required to appoint a guardian
• Treatment decisions could be delayed during legal proceedings
• The person appointed might not be who you would have chosen

Court Proceedings Are Public and ExpensiveIf you become incapacitated without a health care proxy, your family might need to petition the Probate and Family Court for guardianship—a process that is:

• Public (creating court records of your personal medical information)
• Expensive (typically costing thousands in legal fees)
• Time-consuming (often taking weeks or months)
• Potentially contentious (if family members disagree)
• Ongoing (requiring regular court reporting and oversight)

A properly executed health care proxy avoids this entire process, keeping medical decisions private and in trusted hands.

What a Health Care Proxy Does (and Doesn't) Do

Understanding the scope and limitations of a Massachusetts health care proxy is essential for proper planning:


What a Health Care Proxy Does

A valid health care proxy:

Appoints Your Decision-MakerYour health care agent becomes your voice in medical situations when you cannot speak for yourself, with authority to:

• Consult with your doctors
• Access your medical records
• Consent to or refuse treatments
• Choose healthcare facilities
• Select medical providers
• Apply your known wishes to new situations

Activates Only When Needed

The proxy only takes effect when your physician determines you lack capacity to make or communicate healthcare decisions—not before. When you regain capacity, your agent's authority is suspended until needed again.

Prevents Family Conflicts
By legally designating a specific decision-maker, the proxy reduces uncertainty and potential disagreements about who should make decisions, helping preserve family harmony during already stressful situations.

Provides Clear Authority

Healthcare providers have a clear understanding of who has legal decision-making authority, eliminating confusion and potential delays in treatment.

Remains Valid Unless RevokedUnlike some legal documents that expire, a Massachusetts health care proxy remains valid indefinitely unless you explicitly revoke it or create a new one.


What a Health Care Proxy Doesn't DoA health care proxy does not:







Make Financial DecisionsYour health care agent cannot access your bank accounts, pay your bills, or manage your finances—those matters require a separate durable power of attorney.

Override Your CapacityAs long as you can make and communicate decisions, your health care proxy remains dormant, and your agent has no authority.

Replace a Living WillWhile your agent should know your wishes, a health care proxy alone doesn't document your specific treatment preferences. For that, you need a separate living will or personal directive (discussed later).

Cover Non-Medical Decisions

Matters like housing (outside of medical facilities), legal affairs, or business decisions are outside the scope of a health care proxy.

Continue After DeathThe health care agent's authority ends at the moment of your death. Decisions about funeral arrangements, organ donation, or autopsy are not covered unless specifically authorized in other documents.

Legal Requirements for a Valid Massachusetts Health Care Proxy

Massachusetts has specific requirements for creating a legally valid health care proxy, established under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 201D:

Document Requirements

A valid Massachusetts health care proxy must:

• Be in writing
• Identify you (the "principal") by name
• Designate your health care agent by name
• Grant authority for health care decisions
• Include your signature
• Include the date of signing
• Be signed by two adult witnesses who are present when you sign

Witness Restrictions

Not just anyone can witness your health care proxy. Massachusetts prohibits these individuals from ser
ing as witnesses:

• Your designated health care agent
• Your alternate health care agent
• Your spouse, parent, child, sibling, grandchild, or grandparent (whether by blood, marriage, or adoption)
• Anyone who could be a beneficiary of your estate
• Your attending physician or their employees
• Any administrator or employee of a healthcare facility where you are a patient (if you're signing while in a facility)

These restrictions help ensure independent verification of your voluntary signature and capacity.

Agent Qualifications

While Massachusetts has fewer restrictions on who can serve as your agent compared to who can witness, your agent must:

• Be an adult (18 or older)
• Not be your healthcare provider (unless they're related to you)
• Not be an operator, administrator, or employee of a facility where you're a patient (unless they're related to you or another exception applies)

Beyond these legal minimums, your agent should be someone who:

• Knows you well
• Understands your values and wishes
• Is willing to advocate for you, even in difficult circumstances
• Can make decisions under pressure
• Is reasonably available if needed
• Can understand medical information

Format ConsiderationsWhile Massachusetts doesn't require a specific form, your health care proxy should:

• Use clear, unambiguous language
• State that it is a health care proxy under Massachusetts law
• Specify whether your agent has authority to make decisions about life-sustaining treatment
• Include contact information for your agent and alternate
• Indicate any limitations on your agent's authority (if applicable)

Using the standard Massachusetts form (available from the state) or forms provided by major hospitals ensures these elements are included.

Choosing Your Health Care AgentSelecting the right person to serve as your health care agent is arguably the most important aspect of creating your proxy:

Qualities to Look ForThe ideal health care agent possesses:

Personal Knowledge of You

• Understands your values, beliefs, and preferences
• Has had conversations with you about quality of life issues
• Knows what matters most to you in medical situations
• Has observed how you've approached medical decisions in the past

Emotional Stability

• Can make decisions during stressful situations
• Won't be overwhelmed by medical environments
• Can process complex information while under pressure
• Has the fortitude to make difficult choices

Assertiveness

• Will advocate effectively with medical professionals
• Can ask difficult questions
• Will request second opinions when appropriate
• Won't be intimidated by authority figures or complex medical terminology

Availability

• Lives close enough to be physically present if needed
• Has a lifestyle that allows them to participate in medical consultations
• Is accessible by phone for emergency situations
• Has a relatively stable life situation

Willingness to Serve

• Has explicitly agreed to take on this responsibility
• Understands what might be required of them
• Is comfortable with medical decision-making
• Recognizes the potential emotional toll

Common Agent ChoicesTypical health care agent selections include:

• Spouse or partner
• Adult children
• Siblings
• Close friends
• Nieces or nephews

There's no universal "right" choice—the best agent depends on your specific relationships and circumstances.

Naming Alternate AgentsAlways name at least one alternate agent in case your primary agent is:

• Unavailable when needed
• Unwilling to serve when the time comes
• Predeceases you
• Becomes incapacitated themselves
• No longer has a relationship with you

Naming multiple alternates in order of preference provides additional security.

Who to Avoid Naming

Even if legally permitted, these individuals often make problematic health care agents:

• People who struggle with making decisions
• Those who cannot emotionally handle medical situations
• Individuals with strong personal agendas about medical care
• People who tend to avoid difficult conversations
• Those who live far away or are frequently unreachable
• Individuals significantly older than you (who might predecease you)
• People whose religious or moral values conflict with yours

Communicating Your Wishes Effectively

A health care proxy only works well if your agent actually knows what you would want. The document itself appoints the person, but additional steps are needed to ensure they understand your wishes:

Have "The Conversation"

Schedule dedicated time for in-depth discussion about your medical preferences:

• Choose a comfortable, private setting
• Allow plenty of time without distractions
• Frame it as a gift you're giving them—clarity about your wishes
• Acknowledge the emotional difficulty but emphasize its importance

During this conversation, discuss:

• Your general values about quality versus quantity of life
• Specific scenarios that concern you
• Religious or spiritual beliefs that influence your medical choices
• Previous experiences with family members' illnesses that shaped your views
• What "living well" means to you versus merely being alive

Create Written Guidelines

Support your health care proxy with additional written documentation:

Consider a Personal Directive or Living WillWhile not legally binding in Massachusetts, a personal directive (sometimes called a living will) provides written guidance about your preferences for specific treatments. This gives your agent a reference point when facing difficult decisions.
Your personal directive might address:

• Views on ventilator use
• Feelings about artificial nutrition and hydration
• Preferences regarding CPR
• Thoughts on experimental treatments
• Pain management priorities
• Comfort versus curative care in terminal situations

Create a Values Statement

Beyond specific treatments, document your broader values about:

• What makes life meaningful to you
• Activities or capabilities essential to your quality of life
• How you balance risk against potential benefit
• Your attitude toward medical interventions generally
• Spiritual or religious considerations

Update RegularlyYour medical wishes aren't static—they evolve with:

• Age and life stage changes
• New health conditions
• Changes in medical technology
• Shifts in your relationships
• Evolution in your values or beliefs

Review your health care proxy and supporting documents:

• Every 3-5 years
• After major health diagnoses
• When experiencing significant life changes
• When medical advances create new treatment options

After each review, have a refresher conversation with your agent to ensure continued alignment.

Creating Your Massachusetts Health Care Proxy: Step by StepFollow these steps to establish a valid and effective health care proxy:

Step 1: Obtain the Proper Form

While Massachusetts doesn't require a specific form, using established templates ensures all legal requirements are met. Reliable sources include:

• Massachusetts Medical Society
• Major Massachusetts hospitals (MGH, Brigham and Women's, etc.)
• Elder law or estate planning attorneys
• Massachusetts Department of Public Health

Avoid generic online forms that might not comply with Massachusetts-specific requirements.

Step 2: Complete the FormFill out the document completely:

• Provide your full legal name and address
• Include your date of birth for clear identification
• Name your primary health care agent with contact information
• Designate at least one alternate agent with contact information
• Specify any limitations on your agent's authority (if applicable)
• Consider whether organ donation authority should be included

Step 3: Execute ProperlyMassachusetts requires specific execution procedures:

• Sign the document yourself (or direct someone to sign for you if you're physically unable)
• Have two qualified witnesses present simultaneously when you sign
• Ensure each witness signs the document
• Include the date of signing
• Consider having it notarized (not legally required but adds credibility)

Step 4: Distribute CopiesProvide copies to:

• Your primary health care agent
• Your alternate agent(s)
• Your primary care physician
• Specialists managing significant conditions
• The medical records department at your hospital
• Your attorney
• Close family members

Step 5: Store AppropriatelyKeep the original in a safe but accessible location:

• Not in a safe deposit box (which may be inaccessible when needed)
• Not hidden where others won't find it in an emergency
• Consider a fireproof home safe with a trusted person knowing the combination
• Use a dedicated document organizer with other important papers

When and How Your Health Care Proxy Takes EffectUnderstanding the activation process helps ensure your proxy works as intended when needed:

Capacity Determination

In Massachusetts, your health care proxy only becomes effective when:

• Your attending physician determines you lack capacity to make or communicate health care decisions
• This determination is documented in your medical record
• (If available) A second physician confirms this determination for certain serious treatments

"Capacity" in this context means the ability to:

• Understand the relevant information about your condition and treatment options
• Evaluate that information in terms of your values and preferences
• Communicate your decisions to your healthcare providers

It's important to understand that capacity is:

• Decision-specific (you might have capacity for some decisions but not others)
• Potentially fluctuating (you might have capacity in the morning but not later the same day)
• Not the same as being unconscious (you could be conscious but confused)

Your Agent's Role Once ActivatedOnce your health care proxy activates, your agent:

• Is entitled to the same information you would receive
• Can access your medical records
• Must make decisions based on your known wishes or best interests
• Can consent to or refuse treatments
• Can request second opinions
• Can transfer you to different facilities or providers
• Must be consulted before major medical decisions

Special Situations and Considerations

Some circumstances require additional planning or understanding:

HIPAA AuthorizationThe Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) protects your medical privacy. While a health care proxy generally implies HIPAA authorization, including explicit HIPAA language ensures your agent can access your medical information even before the proxy fully activates.

This allows your agent to:

• Speak with your doctors while you still have capacity
• Review your records to prepare for potential decisions
• Participate in appointments at your invitation
• Build relationships with your healthcare team in advance

College Students and Young AdultsYoung adults age 18+ are particularly vulnerable to proxy gaps:

• Parents no longer have automatic legal authority to make medical decisions
• Young adults often haven't created their own advance directives
• Universities may be located far from family members
• Privacy laws restrict information sharing without proper authorization

Every Massachusetts resident who turns 18 should create a health care proxy, especially before leaving for college or independent living.

Conclusion: An Essential Document for Every Massachusetts Adult

A health care proxy isn't just a document for the elderly or chronically ill—it's a fundamental part of adult responsibility in Massachusetts. Medical emergencies and temporary incapacity can affect anyone at any age, often without warning. By taking the relatively simple step of creating a valid health care proxy, you:

• Ensure your medical care reflects your personal values
• Prevent courts from appointing someone you wouldn't have chosen
• Spare your loved ones the stress and expense of guardianship proceedings
• Reduce the potential for family conflict during already difficult times
• Create clarity for healthcare providers during medical emergencies
• Maintain some control over your most personal decisions, even when you cannot speak for yourself

Unlike many aspects of estate planning that focus on what happens after you're gone, a health care proxy addresses what happens while you're still here but unable to advocate for yourself. It's not about death—it's about maintaining your voice in your medical care throughout your life.

The process of creating a valid health care proxy in Massachusetts is straightforward, inexpensive, and provides immediate peace of mind for both you and your loved ones. Unlike many other preparations we might delay or avoid, this is one document that no Massachusetts adult should be without.
​
This article provides general information about Massachusetts health care proxies as of 2025 and should not be construed as legal advice. For guidance about your specific situation, please consult with a qualified attorney. After all, if you're getting advice about something as crucial as your medical decision-making from an article instead of a professional, you might want to reconsider your approach to health planning.